Sep 10 2008

Spain: Bojan Could See Time Against Armenia (England and France, take note)

Published by Richard under Articles

Bojan Krkic is set to debut for Spain tonight.

Bojan Krkic will soon be so popular that football fans will not know his last name, a paradoxical consequence of already being referred to as merely Bojan.  When you are seventeen years old, already scoring goals for Barcelona and threatening to break into the European champion national team, more than two syllables to identify you is superfluous.  If new Spain head coach Vincente Del Bosque has his way, the Bojan phenomenon will take another step forward in World Cup qualifying.

That’s because Del Bosque plans on getting Bojan some time today when the Spaniards face Armenia in qualifying tonight.  It’s no secret (not even to the Armenians) that Spain is likely to win this qualifiers, and although it may be a bit assumptive to plan ahead after Spain only beat Bosnia 1-0 this weekend, Del Bosque will have Bojan on the bench, ready to play, should Spain perform as expected.

Continue Reading »

Your feedback is wanted! Click here to comment.

Sep 06 2008

WCQ Update: Europe, Group 5

Published by Richard under Articles

Qualification Process

Europe qualifies 13 teams to World Cup 2010 in South Africa. There are 53 countries in the confederation. They are divided into nine group - eight with six teams, one with five teams. The winners of each group qualify for the World Cup. The second place teams are then ranked 1 to 9 based on how they did against the top five teams of their group (this is how the five and six team groups are evened out for tiebreaker purposed). The ninth ranked team is eliminated. The other eight teams are paired off t play a two-leg tie, the winner of each qualifying for South Africa.

Group 5

Armenia 0 2 Turkey

There seemed to be a lot of interest in the Cuba-United States match because of the history between the two countries, but these two nations are not exactly passive neighbors.  While a win would surely have meant more to the Armenians, it was a good result for the Turks, who want into half tied before getting goals from Tuncay Sanli and Semih Senturk.  Turkey started Sochaux star Mevlut Erding up front in a bit of a surprise call.

Spain 0 1 Bosnia and Herzegovina

The groups favorites got three points even if the output was somewhat muted.  Fernando Torres was out, leaving David Villa alone up top.   Villa missed a first half penalty kick but scored Spain’s second half goal off a pass from Cesc Fabregas.  Diego Capel got the start in midfield thanks to David Silva’s absence.  Bojan did not get into the match.

Belgium 3 2 Estonia

And Belgium makes it three wins in three Group 5 matches, with the favorites prevailing in each case.  A 93rd minute goal from Estonia’s Andfres Oper made the final score a little closer tan the match may have been, with that second Estonia goal coming after Belgium had started pulling stars from the match.  One of those stars, Wesley Snock, was pulled one minute before Oper’s goal afte rhe had scored two goals of his own.  The last of those goals, in the 80th minute, came after Belgium’s Steven Defour had broken a 1-1 tie created when Estonia’s Sergei Zenjov erased a Belgium half-time lead with a 57th minute goal.

Group Standings

Rank Country GP PTS
1 Turkey 1 3
2 Belgium 1 3
3 Spain 1 3
4 Estonia 1 0
5 Bosnia and Herzegovina 1 0
6 Armenia 1 0

Where They Stand

This may be the last time Spain sits this low in the group, with their next match being against Armenia on Wednesday.  Turkey and Belgium, who will be fighting for the Group’s playoff spot, p[lay each other, which will give us a godo glimpse into the group’s pecking order.  It will be crutial for both belgium and Turkey to get as many points as possible from the group’s last three teams.  Draws are no good.

Your feedback is wanted! Click here to comment.

Aug 23 2008

Saturday Robinho Update

A series of interesting notes from Saturday’s papers, but nothing to dissuade me from the notion that Robinho will be in London early this week and will be confirmed a Blue shortly there after.  There are, however, plenty of reports that would undermine that conclusion.

Continue Reading »

Your feedback is wanted! Click here to comment.

Aug 19 2008

Olympics: Agüero Awakens to Down Brazil, Set Up Nigeria Final

Argentina’s impressive quarterfinal performance made them slightly favorites to beat an underwhelming Brazil side in today’s Olympic semifinal, but there still seemed to be something missing from a team that was expected to be much more dominant than they have been. With Sergio Agüero’s two goals today, we were shown what that missing element was. The Atlético Madrid star, voted best player in Spain last season, pushed Argentina into the final, one match away from repeating as goal medalists.

The Argentinians will meet Nigeria in a final that was expected to be an encore to the Argentina-Brazil main event, but with the Screaming Eagles beating Belgium 4-1, the final now looks like the main attraction it is supposed to be. Nigeria needed a win over the United States in its last group match to make the medal round, but once there they beat a strong Ivory Coast team 2-0 before dispatching Belgium. Given the United States was undefeated before running into the Nigerians, the Super Eagles have been the tournament’s most impressive team over the last three matches.

If Agüero can play against Nigeria as he did against Brazil, it may not matter. Whereas Lionel Messi carried the Argentinians over the Netherlands in the quarterfinals, Agüero stepped up, scored his first goals of the tournament, and returned the favor against the Brazilians. One (or both) of the two star strikers will need to ascend to similar levels in this weekend’s gold medal match, as Nigeria will be their toughest test of the tournament.

Brazil was not up to that label. Argentina went up 2-0 in the second half on Agüero goals that came six minutes apart, but they were the better team even before breaking through. After the goals, Brazil showed some brief life before becoming frustrated by the Argentinians. That frustration came to a head when Thiago Neves as Lucas Leiva were both sent off for a tackles on Javier Mascherano. For a Brazil side disappointed on again missing out on a gold medal, it was an apt end to their hopes.

Brazil will take on Belgium in the bronze medal game, a rematch of a group phase game the Brazilians won, 1-0.  Their inability to reach the gold medal match will hit Brazil hard, as the team brought the biggest name in the tournament, Ronaldinho, as an overage player in an effort to win their first goal medal.  Although Ronaldinho showed some flashes of his former self, Brazil never played up to their talent.  Dunga’s search for a cohesive lineup over the last two matches failed, and Brazil again missed out on Olympic goal. They not only missed out. They crashed out, losing 3-0 in a match that they rarely contested.

Argentina should not expect such little opposition in the final. Nigeria has come to dub their squad the Dream Team and have high expectations. Their athleticism will keep them in the match, their overage Lokomotiv Moscow star Peter Odemwingie is capable of stealing a winger should the the Nigerians stifle Argentina.

While they should be expected to win their second consecutive gold, the tournament has changed for Argentina. Their toughest match will no long be their semifinal, as was expected three weeks ago. Nigeria will be more than Brazil.

Links
Aguero inspires Brazil demise
Nigeria to meet Argentina
Nigeria reach Olympic final
Argentina routs Brazil to reach another final
Argentina knocks out rivals Brazil
Brazil humiliated by final-bound Argentina
Quick Report: Argentina 3-0 Brazil
Nigeria routs Belgium 4-1 to reach Olympic final
Super Eagles dispatch Belgium
Nigeria 4-1 Belgium: Nigeria reach Olympic final
Nigeria’s four-star show
Nigeria thump Belgium to reach Olympic final
Slick Nigeria crush sorry Belgium
Quick report: Nigeria 4-1 Belgium

Your feedback is wanted! Click here to comment.

Aug 07 2008

Ten Reasons You Should Follow Le Championnat - French Football

Le Championnat, the French football championship, starts this Saturday, marking the beginning to the European club season.

Because of Euro 2008 and the Olympics, the off-season has been squeezed on both sides, making for a much shorter down period than many would have liked.  I, however, can not wait for the season to start, and if you remember the circumstances behind Lyon’s seventh consecutive championship, their quest for their eighth can not start soon enough.

Bordeaux, under new coach Laurent Blanc, transcended the gap between Lyonnais and the rest of the table.  They sat only two points back of the champions on the last weekend of the season.  In that 38th round, Lyon beat Paris St. Germain while Bordeaux tied Lens, giving the holders a four point gap.  It was a gap that near evaporated after Blanc’s side went undefeated in their last nine, with six wins.  Bordeaux had improved by eighteen points while Lyon only slipped by two, foreshadowing a 2008-09 rivalry that will define the season.

While the dominant summer story line has been Lyon’s quest for eight, it bears wondering why Bordeaux can not challenge for the title again.  Their goal differential last season was +27, indicative of a team that was getting by on talent over timing.  They bring back their team in tact, ready to shoot down Lyon, while having added young, star forward Yoan Gouffran from Caen.

My predictions for Ligue 1 will come later today, but if you are looking upon France football from a far and seeing a one team league, consider the first of ten reasons why you should follow this season’s Championnat.

1.  Lyon will be pushed for the title

Bordeaux is not going anywhere.  With a year’s experience chasing Lyon and a little more firepower, they will be as strong.  Blanc’s side took 0 of 6 possible points from Lyon last season.  If they can come up with one win (or draw both matches), the four point gap is closed.  They do not need to improve that much to take the title.

Lyon has responded to this threat be restructuring their team.  They let center back Sebastien Squillaci move to Sevilla, goalie Gregory Coupet go to Atlético Madrid, and famously sold Hatem Ben Arfa to Marseille.  All of these players have been replaced, and in the case of the first two, Lyon’s taken the opportunity to get younger.  How the new additions fit into the squad Claude Puel, in his first season managing Lyon, designs will determine whether Lyon can maintain the league while continuing to push for European success.

No matter if you are looking for continued Lyon excellence or toward Bordeaux to snap the string, it will be a story to follow into May.

2.  Karim Benzema

Karim Benzema (pictured) has been knocked this summer for a Euro 2008 performance that was perceived as disappointing.  I even saw a list that held his two games amongst the most disappointing aspects of the European Championships, a claim that made my jaw drop.  Benzema was playing out of position for a manager who did not favor him.  A classic lead striker, Benzema was lined-up to accomdate the legend Thierry Henry.  Watch Benzema this season and you will see a player who should be accomodating nobody.

Follow Lyon and you will see a player that deserves his reputation.  At 21, he is clearly the best player in the league and probably the best player at his age in the world.  While he has gotten by to this point in his career on his superior athletic ability, he has continued to develop his technical ability and is on the verge of being a player who is consistently considered for World Footballer of the Year.

Get in near the ground floor on Benzema so you will be able to put his career and the French national team’s impending rise into context.

3.  League of Young Stars

Le Championnat has developed Benzema and has readied Samir Nasri for Arsenal.  They are only two of a series of French stars that are coming through the ranks.  The France national team disappointed at Europe 2008 with a series of aged stars.  The squad will reload for South Africa off the prospects blooming in Ligue 1 - prospects who can match technical ability with the youth of any country in the world.

4.  Overall quality is right below the big three

There is this mild misconception that the Bundesliga is the fourth best league in Europe, and while there is no way to prove otherwise, I will argue this point with anybody:  France has the fourth best football league on the continent.  The success of their clubs in Europe can back up this claim, as can watching the games.  The technical ability on display in France can be compared (if not favorably, then closely) to that of Spain and Italy.  The league lacks the athletes present in La Liga and Serie A.  The league is nowhere near as fast and demanding as the Premiership,and it does not have the same drawing power as any of the big three.  But as far as quality of play technically, France is top shelf.

The league is ranked fourth in UEFA coefficients (and has been for a while), one spot above Germany; five above the Eredivisie.

I’m just saying.

5.  Looking for the next, non-big three Champions League winners

It’s been almost five years since Jose Mourinho led FC Porto to the Champions League title.  Since then, the big three have had a stranglehold on the Champions League, with teams from outside their leagues rarely showing well in the knock-out phases.  It has become a quest to identify which club from other leagues might break back through.  When you look around for candidates, Porto, the Bundesliga’s Bayern Munich, and Lyon jump out.

To a greater extent than even Munich, Lyon is turning their attention to Europe.  Winning seven titles in a row will tempt you to do that.  Last year, they lost 1-0 on aggregate in the Champions League Round of 16 to eventual champions Manchester United.  Because they were drawn against United and knocked out so early, fans forget how good their team was.

This season, they have brought in Puel with the mandate to make Lyon a player on the continent.   As the team adjusts its goals, maintains one of the strongest midfields on the continent, and continues to groom Benzema as a player that can steal matches, Lyon will grow as a threat to the continent’s mega-clubs.

6.  For a broader Europe

As the big three leagues have continued to grow in power, wealth, and influence, us fans have seen our exposure to the great leagues in Germany, Holland, and Portugal dwindle.  Russia’s performance in Euro 2008 with a team made-up exclusively of Russian Premier League players reminded the world:  There are many places around the world where good football is being played.

French football has not been overlooked like the leagues in Russia or Brazil, but their exposure is more like that of those leagues than the big three.  Supporting Le Championnat, the Bundesliga, the Eredivisie, and the Portuguese Liga helps broaden the game and, depending on how you view the implications of that, improves the sport by increasing its scope.

7.  African presence in Le Championnat

The benefits of increasing the exposure of these leagues:  diversity.  As fans, we get exposed to more players - different players, different styles.  It really excentuates the beauty of the game, to see how many different styles and forms can be employed to play the same, simple game.

In France, one product of diversification is the African influence.  France’s history in northern Africa has led to a pipeline of African talent being recruited into Le Championnat. Some teams within Ligue 1 will have more than half of their starting XI made up of players with African origins.

The same multi-cultural spirit that’s defined the French national team over the last decade is seen throughout the French league.

8.  The rebirth of Paris St. Germain

One of the interesting aspects of the French league is the lack of clubs in the country’s largest city.  Paris St. Germain is the capital’s club, yet lest season they were almost relegated, needing a run of play over the last rounds to finish in sixteenth.  They found themselves in this precarious position despite winning the Coupe de la Ligue and qualifying for this year’s UEFA Cup.

Their plight and their wont to recover has drawn the attention of a number of expatriate Frenchmen, including Arsenal coach Arsene Wenger and captain William Gallas.  While that Gunner duo will not be in Paris this season, the club was able to convince icon Claude Makélélé to trade Chelsea for PSG to close out his career.  Former Roma winger Ludovic Guily has also returned to try and reestablish the club, hoping to make last season look more anomaly than pattern.

9.  It is the first league out of the gate

If you are like me and do not need a summer break, then the club season can not start soon enough.  Le Championnat is the first of the big leagues to start.  The Bundesliga and Premiership start next weekend, which gives us a whole week to either love French football or over-scrutinize the big three league.

I vote for France.

10.  World Football Postulant will follow Le Championnat with you

Throughout the year, I plan to post match predictions and reviews on Le Championnat, even if time constraints have help me from watching as much as I would like.  It is always more fun following a league with somebody else, so let’s do this together.  Stay with WFP all season long as we follow these and all the other story lines which evolve from one of the best leagues in the world.

Together, we will either become experts on Le Championnat or be berated by an expert who finds us.  I’m looking forward to both possibilities.

Later today, I will be posting my season predictions, as well as may picks for the first weekend of the season.  Please post your own predictions and picks, and we can hold each other to them as the season progresses.

Welcome back, football.  Welcome back, football fans.

Your feedback is wanted! Click here to comment.

Aug 05 2008

More David Villa, Tottenham Rumors

If I had to bet, I would put money on Tottenham being without David Villa come September 1.  Still, there is an awful lot of smoke around these rumors for there not to be fire.  But the sticking points in my mind:  the current club says they’re not selling, and the player and his representation are being coy about it all.  This seems more Juande Ramos trying provide a cash catalyst to the situation.

Perhaps Ramos and Ramon Calderon went to some seminar together in the spring?

Today, new rumors come from reliable sources.  Tottenham is set to offer £32 million for David Villa.  The sale of Dimitar Berbatov would fund the transaction, with the Bulgarian to be moved for £30 million.

That reported chain of events should raise doubts as to the veracity of the rumors.  Who is going to pay £30 million for Berbatov?  The reports make it seem like not only will somebody do it (Barça?), but they have confirmed this to Spurs, who are only waiting to find another striker to finalize the Bulgarian’s signing.  And yet Berbatov still plays in the preseason games, as he did this weekend.  So beyond the fact that Valencia seems ill-disposed to selling their striker, there are problems with this story.

If somebody has confirmed they want to buy Berbatov for £30 million, why wait?  Spurs didn’t wait to sell Robbie Keane to Liverpool, were willing to create a hole in their linep (which, thankfully, Darren Bent has filled nicely), and now Zenit St. Petersburg is holding Ramos over the coals on Andrei Arshavin’s price.

The same rumors that have Spurs making a new, record-setting bid for Villa have them staying in the picture with Arshavin.  It is all very fantastical, but I refuse to doubt anything Spurs-related after they improbably sold Robbie Keane and then decided David Bentley was a good fit.   Just as I may be proven wrong on Bentley, I may be proven wrong on Villa, and the Spain international could be in London by the end of the month.

The move makes sense if Valencia is you think the reports of their debt problems are accurate.  I never know what to trust with those stories because there are so many different ways clubs can elect to report their debt that I always feel like I’m on the end of a marketing campaign.  If Valencia were inclined to see Villa, though, wouldn’t they have done it a month ago, when Villa’s value was sky-high after Euro 2008 and they could spend the next month using the proceeds to procure a replacement?  With their UEFA Cup campaign about to start and a reasonable expectation they will compete for a UEFA Cup (or even Champions League) spot for next season (as well as wanting to defend the Copa del Rey), how does now doing an about face on Villa make sense?

As you can tell by my inane use of questions as writing devices, I don’t think it does.  All this smoke we’re seeing it just that: smoke.  That said, he would fit rather nicely in North London.

Quotes
“David likes London and likes how Spurs play under Ramos. If they present an offer, Valencia will seriously study the subject.” - Jose Luis Tamargo, agent, Villa
“Valencia CF has made no agreement nor are they involved in any negotiations to transfer David Villa and David Jimenez Silva to any club in Spain or abroad.” - Valencia
“It is completely untrue. I have informed both the players and their agents in an official and clear manner that the firm intention of the club is for both of the players to stay with us and see out their contracts.” - Valencia

Links
Tottenham eyeing £60million triple swoop?
Spurs reportedly prep $80M mega-bid for Villa
Spurs set for record breaking swoop
Valencia furious over Villa-Silva sale claims
Valencia determined to keep stars
Valencia want to keep Spanish stars Villa and Silva
Soriano vows to keep stars at Valencia

Your feedback is wanted! Click here to comment.

Jul 31 2008

Almost Lost Item: Lyon Quickly Replaces Squillaci

Last week I wrote about Sebastein Squillaci making the move from Lyon of Ligue 1 to Sevilla in the Spanish Liga.  Perhaps it’s because I have a spot in my heart for the marque clubs outside the big three leagues, but I questioned why Squillaci would want to move.  Little did I know what Lyon already had a plan in place and was more than willing to let their star center back move.

To replace him, Lyon swooped for Ghanaian international John Mensah, who moves to the league champions from Stade Rennais for €8.4 million.  Whether he can adjust to the demands of Lyon will be seen, as there is a difference between the schedule you keep at a club like Rennes (who finished a fine sixth in Le Championnat last season) and what you will be asked to do at Lyon.  With the Champions League and the expectation that you will play deep into both all domestic competitions, the sure number of games will increase, particularly as World Cup qualifying demands the Ghana star.

Aside from that, only differences in style (not so much effect) distinguish Mensah from Squillaci.  Squillaci is the more experienced, skilled, and steady of the two, but Mensah brings and athleticism and strength to the middle of the defense that Squillaci could not.  As with any acquisition, there are risks associated with bringing in a new player - one with a different style of game - to replace a well-established piece.

Squillaci is also the more experienced of the two, having a decade’s worth of football in France on his resumé.  That experience, though, brings with it age.  Lyon is trying to transition from the core which has dominated this decade for French football into a squad which can rule the next.  With Claude Puel, who had loaned out Squillaci from Monaco early in the defender’s career, replacing Alain Perrin, bringing in Mensah and letting Jean-Alain Boumsong help the assimilation made sense.

Mensah is 25 years old.  With Mensah, striker Karim Benzema, newly confirmed Milan Baros, midfielders Jérémy Toulalan, Mathieu Bodmer, and Kim Källström, along with new starting goaltender Hugo Lloris, most of Lyon’s prospective starting XI is 26 years old or younger.  They will be able to transition the remaining veterans - Boumsong, Cris, Anthony Réveillère, Sidney Govou and most notably Juninho - over the next couple of seasons, potentially using Lyon’s every-increasing financial profile, while trying to maintain their run atop Le Championnat.

Quotes

“I had a few offers, mostly from English clubs but I opted for Lyon on the insistence of my agent.” - Mensah
“It’s not going to be easy for me but I’ll do my best.” - Mensah
“I’m looking forward to linking up with (manager) Claude Puel, who is one of the best managers in France and has a great future in the game.” - Mensah

Links

Lyon sign Mensah
Wigan target to join Lyon
Ghana captain Mensah signs for Lyon

Your feedback is wanted! Click here to comment.

Jul 15 2008

Del Bosque Named to Replace Aragones as Spain’s Head Coach

Published by Richard under Spain, Vicente del Bosque

Former Real Madrid manager Vicente del Bosque has been named as the new head coach of Spain’s men’s national team, his first coaching job since leaving Besiktas in 2005.  Del Bosque replaces Luis Aragones, who left for Turcell Super League’s Fenerbahçe after leading Spain to the title at Euro 2008.

Del Bosque’s first major tournament will be the 2010 World Cup in South Africa, provided the Spaniards are able to qualify.  The young Spanish team will be favored to win their first World Cup.

Del Bosque’s first match as head coach will be on August 20 when Spain goes to Copenhagen to face Denmark in a friendly.  The team’s first World Cup qualifier on September 6 when Bosnia comes to Murcia.

Del Bosque won two league titles and two Champions League titles with Real Madrid before being fired in 2003 after four years at the helm.  Under his leadership, Real never failed to reach the Champions League semifinals. In his last year at the Santiago Bernabeu, Real Madrid won the Spanish League.

He moved to Besiktas for the 2004 season but was fired before the end of his first campaign.  Last season, he served as sporting director for Cadiz in Spain’s second division.

He is known as a quiet, deferential coach who is popular amongst his players.  As a midfielder, he spent eleven seasons at Real in the seventies and eighties.

For Spain, this seems like a good hire.  He run of success at Real Madrid is impressive.  Having dealt with the numerous stars apt to be at that club, he will be able to manage the various egos and interests of the Spanish team.  Coaching the La Liga front runners, he was still able to produce titles.  It’s the exact same position Spain will find themselves in come 2010.

Links

Spain appoint Del Bosque
Del Bosque steps in for Spain
Del Bosque takes over as Spanish soccer coach
Del Bosque gets Spain coach’s job
Del Bosque appointed new Spain coach - reports
Del Bosque appointed new Spain coach - reports
European champions Spain name Del Bosque as new coach

Your feedback is wanted! Click here to comment.

Jul 11 2008

Ballon d’Or Edited for, Posted to American Soccer Reader

American Soccer Reader bannerI liked the Cristiano Ronaldo, Ballon d’Or article enough to devote a little more time to it and post it to American Soccer Reader.  It can be found here.  In the wake of Euro 2008, a lot of Spain supporters excited about Iker Casillas or Fernando Torres winning the award have found the article.  Hopefully, the readership at ASR will find the article as interesting.

Links

American Soccer Reader
Cristiano Ronaldo Could Lose Out on Ballon d’Or (ASR version)
Ronaldo Could Lose Out on Ballon d’Or (WFP version)

Your feedback is wanted! Click here to comment.

Jul 09 2008

Ronaldo Could Lose Out on Ballon d’Or

Manchester United  attacker Cristiano RonaldoThe level of anti-Cristiano Ronaldo sentiment should not be underestimated, though if you ever find yourself doing so consider reports out of Italy today saying Iker Casillas and Fernando Torres are favorites for the Ballon d’Or - the most prestigious individual award in the footballing world.  Torres certainly had an incredible season, and although I seem to have slightly less regard for Casillas than most, people who know a lot more than I do about the sport have given him tremendous credit for Real Madrid’s success.

Beyond their accomplishments during their club seasons, the capper to their Ballon D’Or resumé seems to be Spain winning Euro 2008.  That is where I see the breakdown in logic.

If you grant that Ronaldo was generally considered to be the favorite for the Ballon d’Or at the end of the club season (and if you don’t, you can stop reading now) you have to ask if the performances of Fernando Torres or Iker Casillas in Euro were sufficient to bridge the gap between them and Ronaldo.  For now, let’s just set aside the idea of defining what that gap was, and let’s also grant the Ronaldo’s one goal in three games performance for Portugal in the tournament did nothing to lengthen that gap.

Torres, until he scored the winning goal in the final, was generally derided for having a disappointing tournament, a view I completely disagree with (I named him to my best XI for the tournament).  He was being substituted in each match, and while some questioned whether that was wise of Luis Aragones, some also advocated giving Daniel Guiza, Torres’s replacement, a greater role.  While Torres may have decreased the distance between him and Ronaldo, this is not the resumé of a Ballon d’Or winner.

Then there is Casillas, who I also named to my Euro 2008 XI.  Casillas’s shining moment was the penalty shootout win over Italy, but beyond that he was untested.  The ten players Spain had in front of him made it a rather boring tournament for Spain’s captain, the pre-kicks Italy match included.  Was that performance against Italy enough to bridge his gap from Ronaldo?

Whether you think Torres or Casillas deserve the award, you should allow that the shift in opinion that has happened over the last two months may be more about Ronaldo than either of these players who might win the award.  Perhaps people have grown weary of the Real Madrid speculation.  That’s understandable.  Perhaps the voters look unfavorably on his style and the various eccentricities of his game.  That is also understandable, but it is not fair to use these things as reason to change your view of Ronaldo’s performances.  Ronaldo, being the front-runner for this award for so long, has been analyzed and scrutinized in a way Torres and Casillas have been able to avoid, and to withhold a vote for him because of that scrutiny  can not be fair unless you wait six months to cast a vote and during that time hold Torres and Casillas to the same standards.

That basic unfairness is not the only problem I have with the Casillas and Torres candidacies.  How did these two players get singled out to be the probables to benefit from Ronaldo’s star falling?  It’s an easy question to answer.   They are the players from the Spain team who best fit the standards for this award.  Still, that Spain squad was defined by team-wide success that does not lend itself to this kind of individual award.  How can you single out Torres or Casillas as being individual beneficiaries from the team’s performance when you see how Marcos Senna, Sergio Ramos, David Villa, Carles Puyol, and David Silva played?

What’s more, why is this being restricted to only Spanish players?  If we are going to reconsider Ronaldo’s claim to the award, we should not let the achievement of a Spain side ill-suited towards individual recognition limit the candidates.  When you compare Casillas’s resume to that of Edwin van der Sar, who looks better?  Both won their club league, and although Casillas’s health during the season is a point in his favor (van der Sar missed time during Manchester United’s season with injuries), van der Sar had a much harder time of it in the Champions League than Casillas had in Euro 2008.   Until the Netherlands was eliminated from Euro, van der Sar had outplayed Casillas and been one of the best goaltenders in the tournament.

And why isn’t Michael Ballack being considered?  He was Chelsea’s best player, as well as Germany’s, and was a decisive force whenever he was on the pitch.

Van der Sar.  Ballack.  Casillas or Torres.  It doesn’t matter.  If what the stories linked below say is true, this award has become less about who will win it than making sure Cristiano Ronaldo doesn’t win.

I hope after the award is given, this write-up looks reactionary; however, I doubt I would have bothered if I didn’t feel that this scenario was possible.

Links

Cristiano Ronaldo Could Miss Out on Ballon d’Or (edited for American Soccer Reader)

Italian Press: Casillas & Torres Favorites For Ballon D’Or

Reports: Casillas, Torres favorites for Ballon d’Or

Your feedback is wanted! Click here to comment.

Next »